Possibly the best reason for home education I've seen today

Timesonline Children ‘no longer reading for pleasure’

An emphasis on “functional literacy” in the classroom has left little time to read for pleasure, it was claimed.

The comments by Frank Cottrell Boyce, who won the Carnegie Medal for children’s writing following the publication of his book Millions, come as a new campaign is launched to promote reading.

When are ppl going to work this one out? Reading is important, it’s very important. I am thrilled that both my children can read. But if all they could read were functional worksheets, and they’d never picked up a book for its own sake and read it to cover to cover, I would not count their reading skills as worth anything.

Once a child can read, and choose to read, and that can be anything from the side of a cereal packet, to a Harry Potter book 😉 to an encyclopedia to a cbeebies website then the world is their oyster. If they think of reading as just a skill to be employed in a lesson and never read a word otherwise then effectively they can’t read.

I had a child like this in my class last year. She could read, but had never picked up a book by preference outside of class and hated our quiet reading sessions. I soon realised this was because she had been pushed to read things “at her level” and had never enjoyed anything she had been given at her extremely good private school. It tooks weeks to persuade her that she could start a book and decide she didn’t like it and put it back, longer to get her to realise that she wasn’t limited to one section of the shelf by age or gender or anything else. Then she took off, reading Dick King-Smith, probably technically below her level, certainly easy for her, but enjoyable and for the first time ever, I was told by her overjoyed mum, she was picking books up and reading them at home as well as talking about what she was doing in class.

I count that as the single best achievement of my short teaching career 🙂

Did I improve her vocabulary? Probably not. Her grammar? Doubtful. Her spelling? Unlikely. But her skillset, her enthusiasm, her happiness? Oh yes.

So that girl is now a reader, and it really didn’t take much, just offering her a range of books, and persuading her to explore. The fact that I’d read aloud a book by that author, The Hodgeheg, to the whole group and she’d really enjoyed it did influence her choice, so it would appear reading to children, even older children, is a good strategy. But you all knew that didn’t you?

Sorry, it’s a hobby horse of mine. And yet another reason why my children are staying at home, with me. Where reading is fun, not a chore.

Comments

8 responses to “Possibly the best reason for home education I've seen today”

  1. Is there room for two on your hobby horse?
    Couldn’t agree with you more.
    Want to say much more but can’t find the right words and the timer has just gone off so lunch is calling!!xx

  2. The unfortunate part of it all is that if they let them read for enjoyment then they would develop skills.

  3. Absolutely. I also think that there is a prejudice that says that everyone should be constantly devouring fiction. Some people love to read fiction (like me!) and some don’t. Some people go through phases of reading and phases of not reading. If people stopped being so stressed about what children are reading then it could only help.

  4. Totally agree with you on the fiction/ non-fiction thing, it was another thing that we differed from the norm on. All children had a self-chosen reading book – for one of the boys that was either a science text book or a horrible history. Didn’t matter to me!

  5. I could not agree with you more. We’re just starting out with letters (Jude is 3 1/2) because he has shown an interest and is ‘spotting’ them everywhere. We do a bit if he wants to, not if he doesn’t – because he’s at home I know exactly where he is up to and what he feels like / is capable of. I hope reading will NEVER be a chore for him.

  6. Learning to read for enjoyement has always been our main for HE’ing. I agree, that if you can read, the world is indeed your oyster. I love the fact that Angel enjoys reading.
    I used to read only non-fiction as a child.

  7. I quite agree 🙂

  8. move up on the hobby horse – room for one more?!
    I’ve noticed that parents who complain about their children never reading by choice, often don’t much themselves either…or only out of sight of the children, so it’s hardly surprising is it?
    My hubby and I read books, magazines, comics, graphic novels, newspapers, fiction, non-fiction, blogs, teletext, cerial packets etc.
    We read at meals (well, bfast and lunch, it’s not allowed at dinner) in the toilet, in the bath, in bed, in the living room, while waiting at Karate gradings, waiting rooms, and outloud to everyone including each other.
    Books aren’t off limits to any children, however young (with the possible exception of library books if said child is a baby in a ripping phase) and indeed we’ve had remarkably few rips – five children and probably only four or five if that. Apart from magazines and newspapers and catalogues of course, that, when finished with are MADE for distruction, if you see what I mean!
    Why? that’s what happened in our families, so it just happens… Luck for us I suppose, but interesting to look at and think about.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *