I think I know why babies get weaned around 4 months…

The last 48 hours soa has been continuously hungry. She was peaceful and easy on Sunday, but then Sunday night morphed into a starveling who needed both breasts every two hours. Yesterday I was a pale shadow of myself – not because of the actual feeding, but because of the lack of sleep around it.

I am not good on interrupted sleep. I remember being so shattered when Small didn’t night wean until around 18 months, and how pathetically grateful I was when he finally did. (@ThePortico I’m hoping that if necessary I can repeat the magic visit with soa in a year or so? 😉 )

So yesterday was tough – she continued to feed very often, and the only breaks were things like walking to Beavers with Small (good walk actually, and seemed to settle him down a little, so that was good. Plus he didn’t seem nearly as upset by leaving the house, wonder if walking to a place makes it feel nearer and therefore more under his control? Hm). Sitting at Beavers with a book (Mindfully Green: A Personal and Spiritual Guide to Whole Earth Thinking since you asked so nicely. Quite nicely written with an unexpected Buddhist slant – well, I hadn’t expected it anyway – but so far lacking anything much in the way of new or practical ideas. I am only in part 1 of 3 though.) I fed her pretty continuously for about 40 minutes, then we wrapped up again and walked partway home, meeting Tim at the convenience store where he was grabbing milk.

Milk was a good thing to have bought. We’d run out of yoghurts and bourbons, Small’s desserts of choice, so it was emergency pancakes for afters instead. Not a thing that’s ever going to give rise to complaints from me. I love pancakes. So does Small it appears 😀

Anyway, I’ve drifted a long way from the original topic. At our baby massage class, soa is the only baby still exclusively breastfed, and one of only two not already being weaned. This despite the official advice that babies should start weaning around six months and not sooner. The thing is, by this stage they look about ready. They are almost sitting up, and pretty much everything they grab heads into their mouths, increasing the feeling that they are really hungry.

But I know soa isn’t really ready. She is satisfied by my breastmilk, even if it sometimes feels like she’s going to wear out the delivery mechanism. I am fortunate enough to have a hugely supportive network of family and friends accepting of my choice to keep on with the breastfeeding and so far I haven’t had so much as one dismissive comment while out and about. So we’ll soldier on through, and I hope you’ll all forgive me for incoherent blogposts brought to you one handed and with matchstick propped eyelids.


Home Ed Inspiration, Ideas, and Activities

Click the links below and scroll through my collection of ideas, workshops, excursions, and more to discover practical everyday activities you can do together in and around your home classroom.


Comments

8 responses to “I think I know why babies get weaned around 4 months…”

  1. I remember this stage sooo well. I think it’s the worst growth spurt of them all because it clashes with the ‘shouldn’t she be on solids by now?’ comments! Some of my relatives still berate me for not spoon feeding Frankie at 4 months, and they don’t understand why she eats a wider variety of food than they do!! The experts say breastfeeding and baby-led weaning are best for development, but I just do it because it’s easier for me!
    .-= Rita´s last blog ..The end of the world as we know it =-.

  2. I think that you know what is best, so go with it. Mine were all different, the last one I can’t even remember! But he must have weaned because he ate sausages and mash for tea tonight 🙂
    .-= kellyi´s last blog ..Life. On Mondays:: windows =-.

  3. I do think you are right in some ways Jax, but in other ways… some babies are definitely ready at 4 months for a bit of solids. I totally breastfed on demand and was willing to carry on for as long as any of mine wanted to. But the key word here is ‘baby-led’! Mine were all grabbing at spoons around the table around 4 months (I’d often be feeding them whilst feeding myself) ~ they would be chomping whilst watching us and wagging with each mouthful that headed towards my mouth (bless!). I decided to offer just a little rice mixed with breastmilk and they all took to it like ducks to water ~ no spitting out AT ALL ~ straight down and demanding more!! I’m not sure what the reasoning behind the extended breastfeeding advice is from the government, but I have a feeling it is to do with making things simple! I remember the advice when I introduced solids to mine was nothing with eggs, gluten, dairy or meat in (early introduction of all of the above can lead to various digestive problems in adult years. Now that meant, for the times I chose to use jar foods, reading the labels VERY carefully as the age recommendations on them were based purely on consistency NOT content!! So many many ‘suitable from 4 months’ jars contained a multitude of the ‘not before 6 months’ foods! Baring in mind that often the less well educated mothers are the ones to use the most jars this was not good news. Even some of my friends just assumed that because the label said it was ‘suitable’ it must be!! SO – in an attempt to make things less confusing, and a failure to get baby food companies to toe-the-line, it is safer for the babies & less complicated for the mums, to simply recommend exclusive milk-feeding until 6 months ~ a wise move yes, as in real terms milk is all the baby NEEDS for that time. BUT some babies, with educated mothers are not harmed and positively enjoy the experience of a little rice, fruit and veg a little sooner! 😀
    .-= Caroline´s last blog ..Bullet Points =-.

  4. @Rita I do confess that I think breastfeeding, once you get past the pain (ime there is always pain in the first few weeks, regardless of how good the latch is – if nothing else you do something daft overnight when you’re tired and trying to feed lying down and it all goes horribly wrong), is the easy way out, not having to schlep bottles around with you, pr worry about sterilisnd and so on. I feel much the same about baby led weaning, no making of purees and so on.
    @kellyi ain’t that the truth. Big was weaned around 4 months as that was the guidance then, and she ate well then and eats well now. Small didn’t really start weaning until 6 or 7 months, he just wasn’t all that interested, and tbh he isn’t now either.

  5. @Caroline think I was commenting as you were there 🙂 As I said above I think Big was fine with it, and as and when soa shows a real food interest we’ll follow her lead, even if she hasn’t hit the magic 6 months. I think that mothers who are paying attention to their babies and their nutritional needs won’t go terribly far wrong.

  6. We had one 4-months and one 8-months for weaning. They both showed much the same signs, though we did offer the 8-month baby food and we’d never offered the 4-month baby anything. I did feel I had to be more careful with allergens for the 4-month one though.

  7. babieswhobrunch avatar
    babieswhobrunch

    good for you. even if you were stopping, good for you. but especially good for you that you are still going. i don’t think enough people say that….

  8. @Ailbhe not unlike my two then 🙂
    @babieswhobrunch thank you.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Get in Touch

Need support for your home ed journey? Looking for tutoring for your young person? Have an idea for a collaboration? I’d love to hear from you!

How I Can Help

After 20+ years of home educating my four children (two now adults), I’ve gathered a wealth of experience that I’m passionate about sharing. Beyond blogging and guest writing, I offer several services designed to support families on their home education journey.

Resources to Support Your Home Ed Journey

I’ve put together a collection of resources that I’ve genuinely found useful over the years—things that have actually made a difference in our home education. Whether you’re just starting out or looking to freshen things up, there’s something here to help. These are the tools, guides, and materials I’d recommend to a friend, because they work.