Would someone please explain

what social skills you are supposed to learn from going to school? How come you need to go to nursery to learn how to go to school? Doesn’t any of this strike any member of the public as just a touch on the ridiculous side? Try the answers to this grauniad question if you feel like reading and weeping.

Today, after I’d got ludicrously cold and wet in a field in Halifax (unfortunately, I don’t believe anyone took a picture of me sitting in a wheelbarrow while some guy poured a bucket of cold dirty water over my head – even my knickers were wet! ) I went back to a colleague’s house to get warm and dry. After we’d eaten (she cooked for me) and talked about work (sad, I know) we got on to life in general, and she asked about the rules and regulations around home education.

There aren’t really any, I said, and explained the current legal position. And then she asked about socialisation. Please tell me, I replied, in what other situation in your life you are required to spend your entire day with approx 30 other ppl selected purely on the face their age is within 6 months or thereabouts of yours? She agreed, and recalled that when she met my children they were extremely capable of holding (slightly odd) conversations with all and sundry, not doing the common small child thing of just staring at the strange adult.

(On the offchance that S finds her way to this blog, this is not a rant aimed at you at all, it’s been bubbling up for a while!).

So school socialisation is not really an applicable social skill for day to day life is it? In fact, I think it goes a long way to explaining the disaffection of today’s teenagers – they are lumped in together, herded from place to place, dismissed as unimportant and unintelligent, non contributory and then suddenly, that’s all their fault. What, are they supposed to be grateful for this treatment? Returning to the conversation with my parent’s friends yesterday, they were recounting the work experience saga they are undertaking. Apparently all year 10/11 children now undertake 2 weeks work experience. This is not, though, supposed to allow them to necessarily experience the work that they are interested in, as they mentioned the boy who wanted to go into the army, who ended up spending two weeks in a hairdresser! It’s supposed to introduce them to the idea of working. Which is fundamentally different to school how in this situation? You go somewhere you don’t want to be and get told to do something you aren’t interested in doing. :/ Point proved I think.

I would just like to know how socialisation and school have come to be synonymous, in the same way they’d like us to believe that school and education are synonymous, rather than the reality for many children that they are actually polar opposites.


Home Ed Inspiration, Ideas, and Activities

Click the links below and scroll through my collection of ideas, workshops, excursions, and more to discover practical everyday activities you can do together in and around your home classroom.


Comments

11 responses to “Would someone please explain”

  1. I suppose if you consider the true meaning of ‘socialisation’ (as opposed to ‘socialising’) then school tries to actually do what the ptb want it to – it tries to socialise you into a culture that expects you to conform and to not question authority. Unfortunately it forgets that most humans rebel against being forced to do something so it’s not working ie. school children don’t do what they want them to. If they really wanted us to conform, they’d find ways of doing it…sorry…I’m feeling that this comment is getting a bit political now – better stop writing 🙂
    Cx

  2. What a load of rubbish in those Graun answers! I haven’t heard so much nonsense in ages.

  3. I agree with you that school is probably the worst place to learn social skills. My arguement has always been similar to yours but to add to that, in the playground situation, you cannot get away from people you don’t like, the very people that as an adult, you would *choose* to stay away from. School removes your choices and freedoms, and does not cater for the many personalities of the human race, nor can it ever do so.
    I also have to agree with Clare entirely.

  4. and how many times were we told “you’re not here to socialise” when we attemped to speak to a fellow pupil in class? School has just become the ‘norm’ so people judge other forms of education against it instead of thinking out the issues… nice post. I’m still unsure what you were doing in a field in a wheelbarrow – I think I must have missed something or you’ve taken up a most unusual hobby?

  5. New car. She really wanted a Reliant Robin, but they don’t make them anymore. 🙂

  6. It was It’s a knockout, Lucy, sponsorship details in a post below 🙂

  7. yes I went through to the justgiving site as I know what to do there – so know all about your antics now 🙂 However I would like photos of your new car 😉

  8. hmm total bollocks isn’t it. but school does give a ready handle to meet and find friends, that can be difficult otherwise in a rural setting. [not impossible!]

  9. Totally agree with you , I was asked this today too, from my experience school doesn’t have much time for socialising nowadays anyway.

  10. Yes, I agree with the point about school and sociallising, though I get a bit frustated sometimes that we don’t get to see many kids as most of them are locked up in schools all day, it starts feeling like the pied piper has just been. in fact I have a post brewing on this subject- just havent found time to write it yet (maybe this is all I will manage right now!)

  11. yet there must be something in it – I think one of my girls’ main reasons for staying at school is that they enjoy the social side of it.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Get in Touch

Need support for your home ed journey? Looking for tutoring for your young person? Have an idea for a collaboration? I’d love to hear from you!

How I Can Help

After 20+ years of home educating my four children (two now adults), I’ve gathered a wealth of experience that I’m passionate about sharing. Beyond blogging and guest writing, I offer several services designed to support families on their home education journey.

Resources to Support Your Home Ed Journey

I’ve put together a collection of resources that I’ve genuinely found useful over the years—things that have actually made a difference in our home education. Whether you’re just starting out or looking to freshen things up, there’s something here to help. These are the tools, guides, and materials I’d recommend to a friend, because they work.