BBC NEWS | Politics | Poor 'may start learning at two'

BBC NEWS | Politics | Poor ‘may start learning at two’

Children from poor families could begin pre-school learning at age two to help give them more stability and stimulation, MPs have heard.

and

The government is piloting this type of provision for 12,000 two-year-olds in some of the poorest areas of the country.

Ms Hughes ruled out giving grants to grandparents who look after children whose parents are too busy.

So this is about removing them from home and family environments and getting them into institutions nice and early. Don’t get me wrong – there are some nurseries that are lovely, and I really do believe that Big was better off in a nursery than she would have been at home with me full time. By the time I’d had Small I was a very different person, and home was a good place for them both.

But to assume that because a family is poor that the best thing to do is shove the children into a ‘a good quality pre-school learning environment’ is precisely the wrong thing to do. Children need to be in families. If the families aren’t stable environments (though I’d question what right anyone has to judge an entire section of society merely on the basis of their income) and we’re going to throw tax payers money at the children anyway, throw it at the home lives. Grants to grandparents to look after grandchildren would be only fair tbh, you can get grants for all sorts of other childcare, why not assist the families direct?

Gill has another take on this as well.


Home Ed Inspiration, Ideas, and Activities

Click the links below and scroll through my collection of ideas, workshops, excursions, and more to discover practical everyday activities you can do together in and around your home classroom.


Comments

8 responses to “BBC NEWS | Politics | Poor 'may start learning at two'”

  1. It is a worrying line of thought, and I agree with your views on it too. But I won’t start really panicking until they make it compulsory. They wouldn’t do that. … Would they?

  2. Poverty never gave anyone freedom, did it?

  3. > Poverty never gave anyone freedom, did it?
    .. neither did money!
    I agree that putting children into nursery, just because the family is poor is wrong. I suspect that the reporting of this does not necessarily reflect the intention: that poor families are offered help. (I have an equally low opinion of news media and government alike.) This is yet another step towards the scary world predicted by George Orwell.
    Oh, no! Thought-crime! The government knows best, really: I’ll be a good boy, honest gov’.

  4. Maybe they use the term ‘poor’ because they can’t think of politically correct wording for ‘teenage drug addicts who shout their kids into the corner all day'(sorry if anyone finds that offensive). I suppose if they use income as a measure there’ll be a lot of ‘good’ parents who pack their kids off thinking they are doing whats best for the child.

  5. “Poverty never gave anyone freedom, did it?”
    No, “work makes you free”.

  6. “… neither did money!”
    How? Money means you have more choice in the world.
    Also, the goverment is not after rich people, is it?
    “No, “work makes you free”.”
    Work, as giving away your time for money, is not the best way to make money. Ask Bill Gates.

  7. I’m not sure money does always give you more choice. There’s a balance to it, as there is with pretty much anything, and not enough money is certainly wearing, but I’m not utterly convinced that lots solves all the problems.
    I think Bill Gates did work rather hard to begin with you know.

  8. Leo, I was referring to this use of work makes you free

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Get in Touch

Need support for your home ed journey? Looking for tutoring for your young person? Have an idea for a collaboration? I’d love to hear from you!

How I Can Help

After 20+ years of home educating my four children (two now adults), I’ve gathered a wealth of experience that I’m passionate about sharing. Beyond blogging and guest writing, I offer several services designed to support families on their home education journey.

Resources to Support Your Home Ed Journey

I’ve put together a collection of resources that I’ve genuinely found useful over the years—things that have actually made a difference in our home education. Whether you’re just starting out or looking to freshen things up, there’s something here to help. These are the tools, guides, and materials I’d recommend to a friend, because they work.