A niche too far

As I’ve mentioned before, I didn’t set up as a mummy blog. I don’t think there really was such a thing when I started! And I don’t categorise myself that way now either, which is probably why I have a technorati authority of 1 😉 Just too many posts that don’t really fit into any particular category, and probably a few too many posts that are just day to day life.

Now, as I’m bumbling around trying to build the blog a little so that I can use that experience to build a writing career, I’m finding that I’m very much moving out of my comfort zone. I’m second guessing everything I write, each comment I make, where to enter my blog in linkies, whether to have a linky on my blog. I don’t want to link bait or beg for comments (and yes, I did change the first term I used there as being unsuitable for this blog!) but if I’m going to make it, I do have to raise my profile a little.

So I’m finding I have hard decisions to make and that it’s even tougher to break into blog friendship circles that have grown up and become firm without me even noticing their arrival.

I suspect that’s mainly because of how this blog grew. It grew in a group of friend’s blogs, we had memes that leapt from blog to blog, we even had a quizilla quiz (sadly long gone) to find out which blogring member we were. We welcomed new blogs and bloggers to our ranks, but with a condition – the blogring is for UK based home educators, mainly those with younger children although I’ve never excluded anyone on age grounds. So our little community stayed comfortably closed and ppl came and went (including me!) depending on their offsprings educational status.

What with one thing and another I didn’t see much of the external world of blogs until some time last year I think, when I somehow fell over the tots 100, and then was thrilled to get on to it. And gradually, from there I started to broaden my blogging horizons, culminating in my trip to Cybermummy last month.

Now I’m trying to make friends and build relationships via twitter and blogs and I’m finding it oh so hard.

You see, I’m not a naturally gregarious person. I’m not vivacious and talkative. I don’t rush up and hug my friends – while I’d kind of like to, I just don’t quite know how to do it. The moment always seems to pass me by, doing one of those awkward to and fro steps where you can’t decide whether to hug or not, and suddenly, you’ve not. On twitter I don’t know what to say, I try really hard to say the right things, but then I worry that I’m trying to hard, and coming across like a mad stalker. The etiquette of the site is very odd, with ppl desperate to increase their follower count and yet you can’t really chat with hundreds of ppl every day.

Not and do the things that count, anyway. I’m falling behind on my friends’ blogs. And on my own blogposts. Staring at stats when I should be keeping up with real connections, not making false friendships with imaginary ppl who probably don’t know who I am or what makes me tick*

Is it possible to do this blogging lark as a home educator, as a breastfeeding, cloth nappy using, feminist mother of three, without selling out and becoming consumerist? Can I do this without handing the blog over to infomercial posts or tarting for readers by posting things that I don’t really feel or believe in?

Am I’m a niche too far, or not far enough? I guess it’s one of those things that only time will tell.

*Note, if you’re on twitter but not imaginary that doesn’t apply to you, so you can’t be offended by it 😉


Home Ed Inspiration, Ideas, and Activities

Click the links below and scroll through my collection of ideas, workshops, excursions, and more to discover practical everyday activities you can do together in and around your home classroom.


Comments

38 responses to “A niche too far”

  1. I guess your post raises two questions: why do you want to raise your profile, and what are comfortable with? In the end I suppose it boils down to this; what is your blog for? Mine is for random thoughts, I’m not disciplined enough to write it regularly!

  2. hmm, as a real friend who developed from the imaginary, i dunno jax, truly. i don’t actually think you can carry on with a blog for friends in the blogring style that will also work as a springboard to being a ‘blog name’. because i think when you blog expecting really only to see a friend comment, you blog as if you are talking to your friends. when you blog with a theme/subject/info, it isn’t. doesn’t mean it isn’t interesting, doesn’t mean you shouldn’t go for it and do it, but it does mean that you are at a crossroads wrt blogging. i think if your own you style was going to give you ‘a following’ for the want of a better word, it would have done, i guess like ppl have read grit without knowing her, due to her style etc. [not that i think her blog is out there on the income generating circuit] i follow your blogs, as i did back then, because of who you are rather than what you write. but i miss the original blogring close friendly feel. things change tho, and i think you should do what is right for you, with regards to what and where to focus the blog on. x x
    .-= HelenHaricot´s last blog ..By- HelenJ =-.

    1. 🙁
      I’m afraid you may be right on lots of counts.
      But I might not give up on any of it, and just carry on with the blogring style posts in between the others anyway 🙂

  3. @Rita I want to try to build a career out of writing, and starting with the blog seems to make sense. I’ve always wanted to be a writer, have boxes of handwritten manuscripts dating back to being a teenager, but right now it feels like I could actually do something with it.
    And as to what I’m comfortable with, I don’t know. That’s what I’m trying to figure out.

  4. i was jan tho, btw! lol for the more or less accuracy of the whole thing!
    .-= HelenHaricot´s last blog ..By- HelenJ =-.

  5. Having just recently got back into Twitter (and this time giving it a proper go) I know where you’re coming from. I does seem a lot better than facebook which seems tot be full of “lol”s, “LMAO”s and “Oh hun”s but sometimes it’s harder thinking of how to respond.
    As for blogging I’m rubbish at it, just lacking in time to finish what I start while it is still relevant. I do read quite a few blogs and of those that I follow (including yours), the one thing in common is that the writers don’t necessarily fit into any niche but they write from the heart about what’s important to them.

  6. 🙂 you should do what feels good for you!
    .-= HelenHaricot´s last blog ..By- HelenJ =-.

  7. ps, just looked to see where my link took me, and such an old blogpost in what seem now to be much easier and simpler times.
    .-= HelenHaricot´s last blog ..By- HelenJ =-.

    1. yeah, I don’t know why it does that – think once upon a time you must have filled in the full link field with that post and it’s been stuck there ever since.
      If you put your blog url in instead it will update with latest post each time you comment 🙂
      Oh, and hugs for the loss of easier and simpler times.

  8. HelenHaricot avatar
    HelenHaricot

    i think they were easier and simpler for many of us really 🙁 however, friendships last and become stronger and for all the different knocks and blows we have all had our share of, we have also had lots of fun, laughter and downright silliness 🙂

    1. here’s to silliness.
      And chocolate. And wine. And late nights around a firepit in the back garden. And more hugs.

  9. HelenHaricot avatar
    HelenHaricot

    🙂

  10. Oh lovely, lovely Jax. I want to come and give you a cuddle. Like you I’ve been online forever, but at Livejournal. So I have a group of friends that I’ve known for a decade, many of whom I’ve never met, but who know more about me than my closest real life friends. And like you the whole bloggy world passed me by – I read By Sun and Candlelight (gorgeous homeschooling blog from New England – look it up) and a few others, but I missed the emergence of the UK blog world.
    The trouble with twitter is there’s a lot of fake Look at me! I’m so lovely! Here I am! Be my friend! LOL! Hugs! people, who are quite obviously trying to increase their follower numbers and drive traffic to their blog. It makes me feel a bit ill, actually. And you come across as yourself on there – I think your genuine, lovely, sincere, thoughtful personality shines through. I’m really glad we met. 🙂
    As for the whole ‘getting the blog out there’ thingy – I think you should just carry on being you. I accepted free tickets for Longleat in exchange for a review of a mobile thingy, and it made me feel like a prostitute and I’ve deleted the post already. My blog is about me, my children, my life. I don’t want to sell out. I don’t even want to write memes.
    If you want to get your writing career moving, what about approaching Green Parent or one of the other magazines with some article ideas? I don’t think you should sell out on here – there are loads of the big name blogs that I don’t bother reading because they’re just reviews and no content. I refuse to sell out my blog with consumerist shit when that’s not the way I live my life. Even SouleMama (another homeed blog) has become so full of sponsored posts that I find there isn’t much content anymore.
    Sorry this is a major ramblefest, and I could go on. And on and on! But d’you know what? I’ll leave you with my favourite Shakespeare quote:
    If you do dance, I wish you a wave o’ th’ sea
    That you might ever do nothing but that
    Move still, still so, and own no other function
    Keep dancing lovely Jax, just the way you are. xxx
    .-= Rachael´s last blog ..hens in the garden =-.

    1. @Rachael you’ve hit the nail on the head there. I do my best to avoid buying stuff, so it feels rather false to accept things I wouldn’t buy for review! Having said that, there are some things already here or on the way, and it would be just as false to fail to do the review in that situation, so there will be some posts of that ilk coming up. Hopefully I can do them in a way that works for me as well as for the companies without completely turning off my friends.
      I have already put feelers out to some sites about writing for them, I think that might be the way to go, although whether it will get me any career development is another thing entirely.
      And yes, it was good to meet you too 🙂
      Fab quote.

  11. Can hugely relate to this. Still reading you Jax, but not many others. I just find the whole person-writes-blog-meets-world so incredibly difficult nowadays – a minefield, in what I thought looked like peaceful green pastures.
    Good luck with your crossroads xx Just wanted to say, I can relate to being stuck at them. (Still am, to some extent, though it kind of resolved itself in the end.)
    .-= Gill´s last blog .. =-.

    1. @Gill glad you’re still around!
      Minefields wouldn’t be effective if they didn’t look like peaceful green pastures 😉
      I think you resolved in some part your crossroads by diversifying your blogs didn’t you? I have considered that, and spinning off a reviews/ sponsored type blog, but I don’t think I have enough traffic that I could drum up that any company would be interested in it anyway. Hohum.

  12. fwiw I think you’ve lost something of the real you with all the wannabe writer stuff – although I realise that’s part of you as well. And personally, I like reading about you and your family, because I know you and am therefore more interested in that than in you as an author, iyswim.
    Twitter, I don’t know – all those damn re-tweets wind me up no end – did you *really* want to win a Mizz annual?!!! I must work out how to hide them from the real stuff.
    I suppose I’d be inclined to separate out the personal from the ‘making money’ side, but that’s just me – don’t know if it’s even possible online, because perhaps you need both.
    Tricky!
    .-= Sarah´s last blog ..This week we have … =-.

    1. @Sarah I think the real me comes in waves actually, and would say it’s def coming out in the writer’s workshop posts. But I know what you mean I think – the chatty over the fence me has receded a little. There are other reasons for that too – it feels a bit wrong to be still chatting about these bigger kids, not least as they can find and read! (Not that I ever put anything on here that I wouldn’t say in front of them (except present lists lol) but still, it feels different).
      I think I will separate out some stuff, I’m looking to do more guest post type things like the Active Fun Kids one, which I think was a bit infomercial like, but was at least a start. And then I might investigate some of the papers/magazines as well.

  13. You know what, just be you. I try and yes I do reviews and sell my soul, but I hope that I get a good balalnce of the things that I do and amke with the boys. Twitter is acout raising the blogs profile, but also chatting to fiends – I love Racheal (she knows that) and I reviewed the mobile Buzz, but didnt get a trip anywhere for it!!
    I met you at CyberMummy and was so glad I did. I love your blog and hope that we are becoming firm friends, but it is all about balance.
    Writing wise I suppose it is about being in the right circles though, I would love to write, but sadly nothing out there paid!
    .-= TheMadHouse´s last blog ..Sponsored Post – Axa Respect on the Roads =-.

    1. @TheMadHouse I really enjoyed meeting you too, and I’m glad we are developing a friendship 🙂
      It’s funny how doing reviews and so on feels like selling out, when going daily to a job didn’t. Or not always anyway! I wonder if it’s because it’s easier to separate the roles out?
      I think I may have lost a bit of balance recently, but I daresay I’ll find it again soon, especially with ppl like you and Rachael who are also treading these slightly commercial paths to keep an eye on me 🙂

  14. Hi Jax,
    I’m an intermittent twitterer, and you don’t ever come across as awkward, or forced. That’s probably your own internal perceptions – I’m the same, that’s why I hardly ever pipe up!
    With your blog – it’s hard to change from where you’re comfortable but your writing style is already interesting. I don’t tend to read blogs with lots of reviews or giveaways anyway.
    Perhaps the only change you need to make is your focus as you write – instead of thinking you’re writing to your close network of friends, you could imagine lots of new friends have arrived who don’t know your history.
    Sorry, I’m babbling. I’m not a writer 😉
    Sam x

    1. @Sam it’s how to put that history across without shoving it in ppl’s faces I guess. If you think about how that would work at a party, it would be very disconcerting if you kept a loop going of introduction all the time!
      And thanks for the twitter reassurance.

  15. In dark and wry fashion, I’ve made it on to a whole new set of blog lists recently, but I can’t say I recommend by entry credentials too much :/
    Goof luck.
    Personally, I don’t bother much with blogs aimed at “being read” – I like the ones that compel me to read with realness.
    .-= Merry´s last blog ..Feelings not Reasons =-.

  16. Giggle.
    my
    good.
    not
    by
    goof.
    .-= Merry´s last blog ..Feelings not Reasons =-.

  17. “I think you resolved in some part your crossroads by diversifying your blogs didn’t you?”
    LOL, nah I actually solved it by not publicly blogging any more. Probably not the solution you were looking for!
    The multiple blogs thing might have worked, if I’d have stayed with it I suppose. But in general I’d echo Merry, Sarah and others by saying that the most readable posts are the ones not trying to be, and anything vaguely commercial is (sorry!) a bit of a turn off.
    It’s that great paradox: you can only be famous by not trying to be famous. Or something. Maybe. I dunno… *wanders off to dig veg plot*
    .-= Gill´s last blog .. =-.

    1. @Gill no, not quite the desired solution!
      I think it’s time I wandered off too.
      (And I do hope these reply comments thread properly when I upgrade the theme!)

  18. I suppose I could say more actually. Our life, obviously, is bound up with the business. We use lots of what we sell and I have no qualms about blogging that and linking back to what we use. But I hope that comes across naturally, because it is natural, not a selling technique.
    I do have a business blog which i use for very different reasons and it consequently has a a small readership, but it is there for google, not people, let’s be honest.
    Recently (since Kandinsky) I’ve thought I might blog some family on PM’s blog, as opposed to the other way round.
    That said,I’m going to offer some products to FB PoP followers later, because I’d rather they went to people who engage, than people who want freebies.
    Business meets personal in a wholesome personal way id what I aim for. I have no idea if it comes across that way. If I used stuff we didn’t sell, I’d still link to it, so I suppose I do practise what I intend, iyswim.
    .-= Merry´s last blog ..Feelings not Reasons =-.

    1. @Merry I suppose when the writing is the business that’s more difficult to do. Hm.

  19. I think (and i’m not sure this can count having only met you irl briefly many years ago!) that you have changed recently and it’s kind of odd, BUT in a good way! I’m really enjoying chatting to you on twitter because it feels less cliquey to me – I’ve been wary of commenting on your blog over the years because of, well, you know, *stuff*, so kind of feel that I’ve not really had the chance to get to know you better and twitter is making that more of a possibility. Also made easier because I think we’re both fairly similar regarding touchy feely stuff, and the only way that people who are less socially gregarious are ever going to be able to get to know each other better, is if one of them makes an attempt to push through that barrier – I think that’s what is different but odd but good about your twitter persona, iyswim? Hope that doesn’t sound rude, it’s not meant to!! Re blogging, you can only try things out, and if they don’t work your old friends, and new ones too, will still be there, and if it does, well then great!

    1. @Tech I’m enjoying chatting more on twitter too, it’s good to get to know you a bit better. Is it really only the once we’ve met? York, right? Doesn’t feel like that somehow.
      Doesn’t sound rude at all, interesting to know that externally it does look like I’m pushing the boundaries as it were, certainly feels like it.
      Am hoping I guess to do all this without alienating old friends and readers, and yes, it’s always good to make new friends, but when it comes right down to it, I just have to do what feels right (no necessarily comfortable!) to me.

  20. Using this blog to get some sort of commercial return would change it, that’s inevitable. I know people say that having sponsored posts etc. doesn’t change what they write, but I don’t believe it for a minute.
    If the motiviation is more to use it to springboard to other writing possibilities, then ISTM that writing something more interesting (!) may bear more fruit in the longer term.
    This ‘oooo! I can write a blog about being a parent, oh I can make some money as well by getting sponsored/reviewing things etc.’ looks like yet another internet fad to me. Seems to me there are a number of people jumping on this bandwagon (not all, somne people have been around for years), but like all bandwagons the wheels will come off, as people realise that actually consitently having something interesting to say is harder than it looks (the escapades of being a parent aren’t really inherently interesting) and companies realise there is little return for their money, or the next marketing fad comes along. for me coming across anything than the odd ‘commercial’ post is an instant turn off – e.g. I’m sorry to say that one glance at The Mad house, and seeing 3 sponsored/review posts on the first page gets me moviong on very quickly.
    I know some people ahve turned a blog into a money making proposition, but they are the exception not the rule
    Having had glance at some of the’mummy bloggers’, the whole thing feels very incestuous to me, with lots of linking to each other etc. but generally I failed to see why I would want to read most of the blogs I came across. what was lacking was a ‘USP’ I guess, and individual voice. Read few and quite often you feel that you could swap posts around from one blog to another and you wouldn’t really notice any difference.
    (Yes, you could say the same about the blogring in the old days esp, but none of us were really aiming to speak to anyone else very much)
    As to seeling out, well, it is different than going too work. You are taking something that has been intesnely personal and using that to sell something (even if it just yourself)
    As for Twitter, well for me anyway it doesn’t really hit any sort of spot. It seems it’s not a fruitful way of interacting for me. As for Retweets – i’m with Sarah, just annoying really on the whole. It just seems like viral spam to me, if I want that I can always go and read my spam emails.
    And yes, I turned off your retweets Jax, as frankly endless mentions of free gifts/comps etc. was just tedious 🙁
    Then again, I’m not a very networking sort of person, and don’t partake in passing on viral ads/video etc. but their success shows that others have a different view.
    Anyway, hope you can find your way to an answer that works for you
    .-= Daddybean´s last blog ..very home education! =-.

    1. @Daddybean to take the twitter thing first, absolutely turn the RTs off. tbh I hadn’t thought any of you lot were still using twitter! I’d stop the competitions, but I have won a few already, so I don’t want to 😀
      On the mummy blogger incestuousness, yes, that has occurred to me too. I wonder how much traffic there is to most of these blogs that isn’t ppl looking for traffic back to theirs in some ways. (To any mummybloggers reading that isn’t meant to be offensive btw, just a wonder!)
      Interesting points on the bandwagon, also something I’d thought. I’m guessing that there isn’t an endless supply of PRs looking for blogs either, but you never know.
      And are you saying I’m not interesting? Humph 😉

  21. Ooops, bit carried away there 🙂
    .-= Daddybean´s last blog ..very home education! =-.

  22. If it was York, It was that time we were at scarborough and had a lovely stream of visitors. Am still thinking about my response to the rest. It will come!

  23. Not got much to say on the selling yourself out thing as think I echo daddybean comment. I don’t like sponsored blogs myself.
    But on the not blogging about older kids – C got very upset when I stopped blogging her life earlier this year. She felt she wasn’t worth talking about maybe? It was largely her prodding that got me starting up again.
    But then she does read our blog (and the others from time to time as she’s incurably nosy!)
    perhaps it’s more that generation that’ll be the next Internet thing. Teens blogging for teens. There’s a money spinner.

  24. You can be interesting Jax :-), but as a rule random reviews of freebie products, or sponsored posts tend not to be IMO.
    I just wonder if such things really help you on your way to making money out of writing. Sure it can make a bit of money for a blog owner, I have no idea how much, but it doesn’t feel like it would be a great deal. And I presume that the payments relate in someway to the blog traffic, seeing as such posts don’t seem to be a reason to revisit a blog, there needs to be some other rather more compelling content there to bring people back.
    I’m probably talking a load of rubbish here of course, seeing as I don’t know anything about this 🙂 But finding some areas which you can write about in a way that interests people enough to come back (if it’s areas of life that interest you anyway, it’s not going to feel so out of place on this blog). Maybe finding a way to create a reason for people to come back – eg Harmony Art Moms sketch Tuesday. Maybe these are areas to explore?
    .-= Daddybean´s last blog ..Making Memories =-.

  25. interesting post and comments! I started my blog mostly for recording, also to hopefully get a bit of support and advice… then I nearly fell on the popularity game thing and wondered why I didn’t get more comments etc etc…
    I just reminded myself WHY I blogged in the first place! 😀
    Making money through it is tempting, but for me, too much hassle I think…
    Interesting point – I’ve stopped reading blogs that are very popular and get 100s of comments. It took too long to wade through all the comments (and I’m bit funny like that, I feel I have to read every one) and I never felt like I became friends with the blogger…
    I’ve stayed, inthe main, with blogs of people who are now friends… it doesn’t matter if I or they don’t blog for ages, we just seem to pick up where we left off 😀
    the whole mummy blogger thing… hmmm. not sure about it really. tho there are one or two people I’m friendly with on twitter.
    last thought – the thing i love most about bloggs, twitter, internet in general, is that it’s perfect for an ostrige like me – anything I don’t like I just ignore!
    ps oh and go for it and good luck xx
    .-= mamacrow´s last blog ..Interlude =-.

  26. I think this is an awesome post and thread of comments Jax!
    I prefer to keep my blogging and money-making completely separate. Come to think of it, I am starting to see real benefits in keeping money making completely separate from all things creative, in order to keep the creative stuff completely pure, and in the hope that the creative stuff done entirely the way I want it will perhaps generate revenue in the long term. And if it doesn’t I’ve not sold out 🙂
    I do think it’s a lot easier to blog about what you want when you want if you have no interest in stats and follower numbers… My life is a happy one without those worries (although when I have looked I am surprised at the traffic I do get tbh). It’s a very personal thing though. Whatever you do I am still here and still a friend!
    .-= Lisa´s last blog ..Asylum =-.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Get in Touch

Need support for your home ed journey? Looking for tutoring for your young person? Have an idea for a collaboration? I’d love to hear from you!

How I Can Help

After 20+ years of home educating my four children (two now adults), I’ve gathered a wealth of experience that I’m passionate about sharing. Beyond blogging and guest writing, I offer several services designed to support families on their home education journey.

Resources to Support Your Home Ed Journey

I’ve put together a collection of resources that I’ve genuinely found useful over the years—things that have actually made a difference in our home education. Whether you’re just starting out or looking to freshen things up, there’s something here to help. These are the tools, guides, and materials I’d recommend to a friend, because they work.